Kiper says Colts and Dolphins are working on 1st round trade

[VeveJones007]

Originally Posted by Spike

Nope, not even close. Edge was an every down back, don't see Barkley in the same class. I saw probably 3 Penn State games this year and was not real impressed. Just my opinion, but Barkley is not another Edge, he doesn't have Edge's vision. Wouldn't waste a number 6 pick on him.

This isn’t a balanced post. While Barkley may not have Edge’s vision or pass blocking, Edge didn’t have Barkley’s big play or return ability. They really aren’t comparable. They have very different skill sets.