Defensive End or Corner?

[Kray007]

We’ve reached week 8, and we probably have a pretty decent sense of the Colt’s needs. Normally, you wouldn’t expect Ballard, or most NFL GM’s, to be busy at this time of the year, looking to swing a trade that alters their team’s trajectory.

If you’re not a serious contender, there doesn’t seem much point in adding a piece that might take you from 6-11 to 8-9. On the other hand, unless you’re sitting at 2-5, you hesitate to take an axe to your roster and begin a rebuild in October.

The Colts, unique in the Ballard era, have a legit opportunity to enter the bye with a record of 9-1 and a two game lead in the race to secure top seed in the AFC.

They, have, however, a daunting 7 game closing stretch that would task even the most elite of teams. The Offense is fine, perhaps great. The Defense, however, has cracks that need to be addressed. At this moment, we have needs at all three levels

Defensive End, Linebacker, and on the Corner.

For purposes of discussion, I exclude Linebacker as a potential target. No serious thought is being given to the potential for a trade to fortify the position. Besides, the acquisition of Pratt and the eventual return of Jaylon Carlies would seem to allay concerns about the position.

So, that leaves Defensive End and Cornerback as primary needs, and I assume, for a variety of reasons, that it’s a binary choice…one or the other. In an ideal world, you’re fielding a defense that covers receivers like a glove and hounds the Quarterback into submission. We saw a little of that from Seattle, who made the Texans look inept.

Who knows; maybe, given time, Chris Ballard will craft one of those in Indy. But, for now, we face a choice. We can help the Corners by adding a pass rusher who harries the Quarterback into quicker throws or we can boost the pass rush by adding a Corner who forces the Quarterback to hold onto the ball because he can’t find anyone open.

Personally, I’ve always figured it was easier to find talent at Corner than it is to get a good pass rusher, and I’m a believer in Bill Polian’s philosophy that the two most important things are protecting your guy and getting to the other guy.

Besides, I find watching Trey Hendrickson level CJ Stroud a heck of a lot more satisfying than seeing Kenny Moore knock the ball down.

Also, it seems to me that the return of Cameron Ward and Jaylon Jones offers some confidence that the situation in the back end will take a turn for the better. At Defensive End, however, I see no internal reinforcements poised to appear over yonder hill.

So chalk me up in the add a DE camp. Who that is, I don’t know. But, I do know Ballard needs to do something. If plan A isn’t available, if a team like Cincinnati isn’t going to part ways with a Trey Hendrickson, move on to plan B. Whatever you do, though, don’t squander capital on another guy who looks good on paper but doesn’t produce. The last thing we need is Dayo Odeyingbo v2.0.

[Racehorse]

I think trading for one of them is more likely to be a CB. Pass rushers usually do not get traded, except for when the compensation is multiple first rounders. A second could get you a quality CB. Heck, a third might be enough.

[Brylok]

Trading significant resources: pass rusher
Band-aid for right now: corner

IMO, the pass rush, right now, is good enough to scrape by. The secondary isn't. They can't cover anyone. Herbert would have thrown for 500+ yards if they didn't have a bunch of drops. That's ridiculous. Chargers had 24 total yards of offense at the end of the 1st quarter. Colts can't cover right now. Might as well have had one of us out there.

We need both and a linebacker. I'm not expecting much of anything. Glad I'm not making the decision.

[YDFL Commish]

Originally Posted by Brylok

We need both and a linebacker. I'm not expecting much of anything. Glad I'm not making the decision.

Apparently the Bengals Logan Wilson is good coverage LB. Anarumo, so I'm assuming plug and play. IMO, I would rather bet on Jaylon Carlies though, especially after adding Pratt.

If we wanna really swing for the fences, the I'm all in on Maxx Crosby.

[Butter]

Crosby seems not to be available from things I have read. I am not sure why they would want to trade him regardless. If they did the Cowboys have a stack of 1sts they could use to get him, seems like a pipe dream.

[YDFL Commish]

Originally Posted by Butter

Crosby seems not to be available from things I have read. I am not sure why they would want to trade him regardless. If they did the Cowboys have a stack of 1sts they could use to get him, seems like a pipe dream.

I'm not that all in. Anything with a 1 in the number is unreasonable.

[Racehorse]

Originally Posted by YDFL Commish

I'm not that all in. Anything with a 1 in the number is unreasonable.

I agree, unless it is 1 Day 2 pick, lol

[ChaosTheory]

I'm very anxious to get Ward and Jones (and even Hilton) back. Unfortunately, it's a patience game there. But I don't know what trade they could make, so I lean towards waiting.

An Edge would be trade-worthy, I don't think the guys we want are available.

And two other things:

1.) The pass-rush has looked better than the sack numbers lately. Brissett and Herbert are tough to wrangle and get down. Problem is they would buy just enough time to find guys open in coverage.

2.) Anarumo seems to have eased off the blitzing the past few games because of the state of the secondary. I think when Ward, Moore, and Jones (hopefully) are all healthy, not only will we cover better, but Anarumo will open up to more creative blitzes. That's a lot scarier to try with Cameron Mitchell and Jonathan Edwards back there.

[AlwaysSunnyinIndy]

Originally Posted by Butter

Crosby seems not to be available from things I have read. I am not sure why they would want to trade him regardless. If they did the Cowboys have a stack of 1sts they could use to get him, seems like a pipe dream.

Agreed. Pelissero wrote the below tweets about Crosby earlier this week:

https://x.com/TomPelissero/status/1980794329045028920

The Raiders met with star DE Maxx Crosby today to let him know they aren’t shopping him and won’t trade him, sources tell me.

While other teams are interested, the Raiders aren’t interested in moving their best player, and Crosby wants to stay in Las Vegas.

https://x.com/TomPelissero/status/1980794852167340097

Nobody wants to win more than Maxx Crosby, and he wants to do it with the Raiders.

Despite various rumors with the trade deadline 2 weeks away, the face of the franchise isn't leaving Las Vegas.