The "official"Colts to get stomped by the phony ponies game day thread

[IndyNorm]

Originally Posted by Colts And Orioles

o


The point was that there is nobody to replace Taylor right now if he were cut immediately, as Chopped Wood professed. It's not a matter of Taylor not being elite, but who out there is just as good as he is and is available as a free agent right this minute.

If NFL teams/coaches/GM's were that reactionary, they wouldn't have a team.

o

No, there isn't anyone as good as JT that we can get off the street. But Steichen should have definitely benched his ass to send a message that dumbass shit like JT did doesn't fly.

[Colts And Orioles]

Originally Posted by IndyNorm

No, there isn't anyone as good as JT that we can get off the street. But Steichen should have definitely benched his ass to send a message that dumbass shit like JT did doesn't fly.

o


I would have had no problem with Steichen benching Taylor for the remainder of the game right after that play.

o

[Thorgrim]

Originally Posted by Colts And Orioles

o


I would have had no problem with Steichen benching Taylor for the remainder of the game right after that play.

o

And here is evidence of an even bigger problem. Just what the hell do you have to do to get benched? If this fucked up play doesn't justify a benching I don't know what does. I guess Steichen doesn't believe in disciplinary measures. I had a coach who was a rah-rah type who wanted so badly to be liked by his players that he never earned our respect. He was a real nice guy but lost the team. I'm sure Steichen is a nice guy too. I suspect he doesn't have the respect of his team tho. Indy seems to be a great place for a player/coach/general manager to collect a check. Not a great place if you're looking for on field success. The organization just doesn't seem to have a winning culture. For this simple minded man I don't claim to have an easy solution but as an observer of the game for 50+ years I can tell you what obviously doesn't work and I'm sure it's quite evident to most of you that the Irsays can't see the obvious or just don't really care as long as they are making a profit and can say "I own an NFL team."

[Colts And Orioles]

Originally Posted by Thorgrim

And here is evidence of an even bigger problem. Just what the hell do you have to do to get benched? If this fucked up play doesn't justify a benching I don't know what does. I guess Steichen doesn't believe in disciplinary measures. I had a coach who was a rah-rah type who wanted so badly to be liked by his players that he never earned our respect. He was a real nice guy but lost the team. I'm sure Steichen is a nice guy too. I suspect he doesn't have the respect of his team tho. Indy seems to be a great place for a player/coach/general manager to collect a check. Not a great place if you're looking for on field success. The organization just doesn't seem to have a winning culture. For this simple minded man I don't claim to have an easy solution but as an observer of the game for 50+ years I can tell you what obviously doesn't work and I'm sure it's quite evident to most of you that the Irsays can't see the obvious or just don't really care as long as they are making a profit and can say "I own an NFL team."

o


In hindsight, the benching of Anthony Richardson appears to have been hypocritical ...... in fact, it was hypocritical in the first place, but now it appears to be even more hypocritical.

Richardson was benched for audibling out of a dumb-ass pass play that Steichen called for a different dumb-ass pass play of his own, and throwing an INT right before halftime against the Texans ....... so he was benched for audibling out of one dumb-ass decision by the coach (to pass the ball to one receiver) for an equally dumb-ass decision of his own (to pass the ball to a different receiver.)


So if Richardson gets benched for being equally as dumb as Steichen, why is Taylor not benched for being 10 times as dumb as either of them ???

o

[ChoppedWood]

Originally Posted by Colts And Orioles

o


In hindsight, the benching of Anthony Richardson appears to have been hypocritical ...... in fact, it was hypocritical in the first place, but now it appears to be even more hypocritical.

Richardson was benched for audibling out of a dumb-ass pass play that Steichen called for a different dumb-ass pass play of his own, and throwing an INT right before halftime against the Texans ....... so he was benched for audibling out of one dumb-ass decision by the coach (to pass the ball to one receiver) for an equally dumb-ass decision of his own (to pass the ball to a different receiver.)


So if Richardson gets benched for being equally as dumb as Steichen, why is Taylor not benched for being 10 times a dumb as either of them ???

o

Steichen is proving to not be very good. I am fine with him being shipped as well.

The whole thing just stinks like shit and it needs a good deep clean.

[YDFL Commish]

Originally Posted by Thorgrim

And here is evidence of an even bigger problem. Just what the hell do you have to do to get benched? If this fucked up play doesn't justify a benching I don't know what does. I guess Steichen doesn't believe in disciplinary measures. I had a coach who was a rah-rah type who wanted so badly to be liked by his players that he never earned our respect. He was a real nice guy but lost the team. I'm sure Steichen is a nice guy too. I suspect he doesn't have the respect of his team tho. Indy seems to be a great place for a player/coach/general manager to collect a check. Not a great place if you're looking for on field success. The organization just doesn't seem to have a winning culture. For this simple minded man I don't claim to have an easy solution but as an observer of the game for 50+ years I can tell you what obviously doesn't work and I'm sure it's quite evident to most of you that the Irsays can't see the obvious or just don't really care as long as they are making a profit and can say "I own an NFL team."

Do you know why it is that the Manning led teams didn't have this problem?

It wasn't Irsay, it wasn't Dungy, it wasn't Polian. It was Manning himself, he was the de facto entire organization. It was PM's way or the eventual highway.

Luck, although a lot nicer about it and more political was much the same, as was Rivers. There is not one leader of men on this entire team.

What identity does the current version of the Colts have? Nothing, because they stand for nothing and are nothing in the eyes of the NFL. Only transcendent players can change that.

Maybe there is a transcendent coach out there that can, but I can't name him.

[Colts And Orioles]

Originally Posted by YDFL Commish

Do you know why it is that the Manning led teams didn't have this problem?

It wasn't Irsay, it wasn't Dungy, it wasn't Polian. It was Manning himself, he was the de facto entire organization. It was PM's way or the eventual highway.

Luck, although a lot nicer about it and more political was much the same, as was Rivers. There is not one leader of men on this entire team.

What identity does the current version of the Colts have? Nothing, because they stand for nothing and are nothing in the eyes of the NFL. Only transcendent players can change that.

Maybe there is a transcendent coach out there that can, but I can't name him.

o


I wish that I could thank this post twice ...... it deserves it.

The Colts were always a bona-fide contender when Manning played for them, when Luck played for them, and even when a 39 year-old Philip Rivers played for them.

o