That's a good point on the QBs, especially Edge since he had 7 years of prime Manning as his QB. Faulk is a little more nuanced IMO b/c he had 3 years of prime Warner and 1 year of rookie Manning. Also, w/ the exception of '22 JT's line has been better than any of Faulk's. Especially for years 2-4 for Faulk which couldn't run block to save their lives.
I think as a pure runner JT is arguably the best, but IMO you have to factor in other aspects of the position as well which as you noted Faulk and Edge were much better at receiving (and pass blocking for Edge) than JT is.
Last edited by IndyNorm; 07-04-2026 at 07:57 PM.
|
07-04-2026, 10:14 AM
Threaded Mode