Dave Toub research

[Puck]

Originally Posted by YDFL Commish

I've said this before; it really doesn't matter what side of the ball most HC's come from in their previous employment. They rarely fix the side of the ball they were hired to fix.

McDaniels would certainly fix the offensive side of the ball

[YDFL Commish]

Originally Posted by Puck

McDaniels would certainly fix the offensive side of the ball

I agree that it's probable. But mostly because of the impotent offense that was run previously.

Remember Brian Billick?

[omahacolt]

Originally Posted by Puck

Here's my issue with hiring a ST's coach. May not be much of an issue but it could be.

What schemes does he bring? Who will the coordinators be? Let's say he goes out and gets 2 coordinators and the defense gets better .... top 10 better.... we get back Luck, and the offense goes back to a top 5 offense....

How long do you think either coordinator would be here? They would get scooped for a HC job somewhere.

My opinion is we need to hire someone like McDaniels or Nagy who would control one side of the ball... as a play caller or has brought in his offense and has a OC to run it, and if that OC gets hired away, the scheme stays the same and the HC could call plays if needed.

This team needs an offensive minded HC more than it needs a defensive minded coach.

JMO
Pete

i get your point but i don't see it as being necessary. subtle changes to an offense is fine.

i think people get way too worked up over manning staying in one system.

[Gimmick]

55 and never been a head coach. Next please.