What if Luck wanted to return next year?
 

Would you want him back? Would it depend on how JB performs this year?

this was already brought up

No, I wouldn't, because the first time he gets injured again, and injuries happen in the NFL to all QBs, we are back in this same spot

Plus I don't think there is any way he decides to play again. He has other interests, he is moving on, he doesn't need football the way Peyton or players of that type do and/or did.

If he comes back, you trade him for a haul of draft picks and let Ballard work his magic

He won't play another down for the Colts. Trade him to Denver.

Of course we should want him back. Elite QBs are exceedingly rare. And there's this:

https://twitter.com/LALeBron23/statu...65492037021697

Welcome him back with open arms. Would love to have him back.

You absolutely welcome him back. There just have to be some sort of assurances that this situation never repeats.

Having said that, there is NO WAY he’s coming back and even if he did, there is NO WAY IN HELL he’s coming back to Indy.

He’d have to have a fresh start.

Trade him to the Giants. Let him deal with the New York media and fans. See how they react to the phantom injuries, quitting the team, and walking off with $25M for nothing. Think Indy fans are bad? Haha...

Looks like they already have the future with Daniel Jones, he has had the best rookie preseason since 2006.

I would unless Brissett becomes a surprise revelation, but I don't think its likely. Even then, it may end up that Brissett signs elsewhere, leaving us in need of a new QB. Luck would be better than any other choice available (Nate Sudfeld is an interesting possibility but still not better than Luck).
Or, Brissett is mediocre, which again leaves us looking for better options, and once again Luck is better than any other choice available.

He is NOT coming back. Among other things has everyone forgotten that he said the year off from football saved his relationship with his wife? Think she wants him playing football again? He is gone for good.