Quenton Nelson (G-ND) Rd #1 Pick #6

[VeveJones007]

Originally Posted by YDFL Commish

We don'twin without Luck and Nelson is responsible for keeping Luck on the field, while Chubb is not. Therefor I disagree.

I probably should have just held my tongue (fingers?) because I'm tired of this debate.

[FatDT]

Originally Posted by Dam8610

Case Keenum is not a viable long term solution at QB. If Elway's plan is to bounce from patch to patch at the QB position, he likely won't have a job for very long. He and Gettleman both made potentially career killing decisions.

It worked w/Manning. Doesn't seem sustainable to me either but if he can keep that defense playing at a high level and roll QBs through without too much trouble maybe he'll strike gold again. It'd be hard to fire a guy that makes two SB wins happen.

[VeveJones007]

@MikeWellsNFL
Interesting nugget on story I'm working on how the Colts selected Quenton Nelson. GM Chris Ballard went to Nelson's Pro Day and "stayed away" after that so he didn't show his hand. Colts didn't bring Nelson in for a visit. He said other teams "track" which teams are at Pro Days

Colts did same thing with Chubb. Reminder: don't read too much into player visits.

[rcubed]

Is it me or does Nelson look like a window licker?

[Chromeburn]

Originally Posted by rcubed

Is it me or does Nelson look like a window licker?

He looks like the hulk with a baby face

[Maniac]

Bills apparently were willing to give up both 1st rd picks and a 2nd rd pick:

https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/h...ey-chubb-fell/

They had that deal in place with the broncos but fell through when Chubb was still there. I'm sure they would have offered the same deal to Ballard, but supposedly he wouldn't budge and wanted Nelson.

Man, I don't know, two 1st rd picks and another 2nd, I think I would have let Nelson go and take that deal.

[Chaka]

It wasn't a freestanding 2nd - the Broncos would have had to return a 3rd to the Bills. My guess is that this component would have disappeared in a Colts trade, since theoretically the Bills were getting a slightly lower 1st round pick in return - so probably our #1 for the Bills two #1s would have been the likely offer.

[Maniac]

Originally Posted by Chaka

It wasn't a freestanding 2nd - the Broncos would have had to return a 3rd to the Bills. My guess is that this component would have disappeared in a Colts trade, since theoretically the Bills were getting a slightly lower 1st round pick in return - so probably our #1 for the Bills two #1s would have been the likely offer.

I doubt it. It's only 100 points difference between the 5th and 6th pick.

[Chaka]

Originally Posted by JesusChrist

I doubt it. It's only 100 points difference between the 5th and 6th pick.

Yes, but consider that the Buccaneers, who had the #7 selection immediately after the Colts, did NOT receive an offer as substantial as the Broncos offer – they received #12, #53 and #56 instead. Using the point chart (which I’m not sure that NFL teams actually use at all), that’s a total of 1910 points.

By contrast, the offer the Bills made the Broncos at #5 was a bit better (nos. #12, #22 and an exchange of a Bills second round pick for a Broncos’ third round pick) and totals 2115 points – assuming the 2nd and 3rd being exchanged were the earlier of each team’s pick.

Thus, if the Bills had offered the Colts the #12 and #22 picks together, the resulting point total (1980 points) would fit nicely between the two offers.

[Maniac]

Originally Posted by Chaka

Yes, but consider that the Buccaneers, who had the #7 selection immediately after the Colts, did NOT receive an offer as substantial as the Broncos offer – they received #12, #53 and #56 instead. Using the point chart (which I’m not sure that NFL teams actually use at all), that’s a total of 1910 points.

By contrast, the offer the Bills made the Broncos at #5 was a bit better (nos. #12, #22 and an exchange of a Bills second round pick for a Broncos’ third round pick) and totals 2115 points – assuming the 2nd and 3rd being exchanged were the earlier of each team’s pick.

Thus, if the Bills had offered the Colts the #12 and #22 picks together, the resulting point total (1980 points) would fit nicely between the two offers.

That's only because the Bucs were idiots. They could have gotten the same deal, so could the Colts. The Bills wanted their QB and would have given that offer to any of the top spots in the draft to get him.