Orlando Brown?
|
Ummm...sure. But at what price?
He is ascending and looks to be about as sure fire thing out there to lock down LT for a good long while. But what would BAL want from a team in order to trade him? I am not sure our 21st pick alone would do it. |
Might want to see if one of our own players can fill LT first. If they can, we can draft a G or RT later. I like Bradon Smith's chances. Remember, he graded out as even more athletic than Nelson. But it isn't a simple position switch. Basically, you learn to do everything backwards than you currently know how.
Also, this is a pretty good tackle draft |
Yeah if smith could move over effectively i would prefer that over nelson, then get a new rt.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Quote:
Or I may be misunderstanding your post. I do that occasionally. |
Quote:
Ha, no worries I do the same. I was referring to the previous post about using our own players. Yes, if we were to trade for an established LT then we wouldnt need any further movement. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
No. This team has shown that it knows how to work with and develop offensive lineman. Draft Castanzo's replacement. Get him on a five year rookie deal. If we want to go a veteran route I would prefer a two-three year deal on someone like Williams. We can take the cap hit this year, the contract can be done so that the last year isn't a huge hit and it stabilizes our line now. Still prefer we draft and develop our own.
|
Quote:
I'm not against drafting a LT in parallel with a Brown trade, in fact I think it would be a wise move in a deep LT draft. With that said, I'm not giving up our #1 for him. |
Quote:
|
I don’t like what we would have to give up for him
|
Quote:
|
He'd be a cheap option for tackle for this year. But then he'd need to be resigned, along with Smith and Nelson. That would make the Colts O-line the most expensive in the NFL.
It would also make that o-line ridiculously good, but come at a price with the rest of the team. |
Quote:
|
I don't think we should go after him. Playing LT for other QB's is a little harder than for Jackson. There is a reason the two Raven's tackles had such a high rating.
D lines have to do bull rushes against Jackson in order to keep contain. If you break contain he is gone for a first down. So that played into Orlando Brown's strength who does best against bull rushes. Against less mobile QB's he will have to play against speed rushers and he will not do as well against them. |
The Colts could go find a quality RT in FA and move Smith to LT.
|
If we had a franchise QB I would say “Hell yeah!”
Instead, since we decidedly don’t, we’re likely going to need the assets that we would trade for Orlando Brown in order to get our QB. Even if we only trade a 2nd for Wentz (for example), trading a 1 for Brown then essentially cancels our draft haul for 2021. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Granted, Ballard is best when he has the pick in hand. His draft selections are just pure gold these past couple of years. However, if you told him he could lock down two of the most important positions on an NFL team with KNOWN high-quality players (that is a projection on Wentz) instead of draftee hopefuls with his first 2 picks, he would do it every year. |
From PFT
https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.co...ugh-for-colts/ Nelson has played tackle, I believe that was his first position at ND |
Now that the Colts have traded for Wentz using only their 2021 third...I would consider a 1st for Brown. We might very well be picking LT with our 1st round pick anyway!
|
Quote:
|
My top option would be to sign one of the 33 year old veteran free agent left tackles (Trent Williams, Russell Okung or Alejandro Villanueva) on a 2 or 3 year deal and then draft an offensive tackle (2nd round or 4th round pick) to play swing / depth for the next season or two prior to (hopefully) becoming the starter.
We need a quality 3rd OT on this team. Employing the likes of Will Holder or Carter O'Donnell in that role sends shivers up my spine. Pinter appears to be solid as depth on the O-Line interior but we need someone who can provide that same depth at OT. |
I really like the idea of spending large on someone like Williams for 2-3 years and developing your next LT. Don’t think Ballard will do this as it goes counter to how he has done things so far. I have to believe that he has confidence in his ability (and the ability of his scouts to find and coaches to develop) to draft our next LT. I believe this is a big part of how he keeps this team financially so stable.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
https://www.indystar.com/story/sport...es/4029529001/ |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
What I don’t understand is that you were arguing not to move Smith from right tackle to left tackle, but we should trade for a guy who has moved from right tackle to left tackle. And if Smith can move it solves a lot of problems, and it would cost a whole hell of a lot less. Less money less draft picks given up, and again whatever that losing value on a player whatever the hell that means |
As a practical matter, its a question of affordability beyond the trade cost. We cannot afford Brown. He's going into the last year of his rookie deal and, simply put, will need to be paid top dollar or he will leave. We also have Darius Leonard's and Braden Smith's second contract coming due at the same time. And maybe Nelson's, though he could theoretically be put off a year with the 5th year option (still at a premium price though). Don't forget we just made Kelly the highest paid center too, and Glowinski's three-year deal will be expiring as well.
Something has to give. The Colts are going to have to make some hard decisions soon. My guess is that Leonard and Nelson absolutely stay, Smith probably stays, and Glowinski is a goner. But the solution is not to add another premium contract on the OL, particularly one from another organization. We need to find a young, cheap player at LT, so the draft is the way to go. |
Darrisaw from Virginia Tech, at #21, and placed next to and learning from Nelson, would settle the issue.
Brown is a pipe dream. There is a reason that Baltimore moved him from LT to RT, he was helped a lot by Jackson's ridiculous athletic ability to escape, and yeah, he will be expecting big, big money when his rookie deal expires. Pass. Get a rookie. This is supposed to be a strong draft for tackles, so now's the time. |
Agree totally with Chaka on this. We can’t afford to pay, long term anyway-might make sense for a couple of years-for a premium LT without compromising another part of line. Ballard can draft. The coaching staff can coach. The draft is the way forward.
|
Here's a little bit of an outside-the-box thought: what about trading Braden Smith at this point? Would he be worth the same or more than Brown?
The good: I don't think his value has ever been higher, and the seed has been planted that he might be able/is open to moving to LT. He's also a year out from a very large contract, and while I think we'd keep him, I'm not sure and Ballard can be pretty ruthless in his cap management. This would of course help alleviate a future cap logjam, and if we are uncertain we will keep him past 2021 then this would ensure we would at least get something in return. The bad: I realize that this weakens an already weakened OL, and I know most OL coaches highly value continuity in this area. Not sure we have anyone on the roster right now who could fill in adequately, so the plan would have to be to draft his replacement this offseason. If a little development time is needed we would need to pick up a serviceable vet replacement on a one-year contract. Anyway, I realize it's not ideal, but the earlier post got me thinking about how we are going to be able manage all these players under the cap in the coming years, and what kind of hard decisions will need to be made (and when it is best to make them). |
Quote:
|
Trading Smith is not something I would want to do. I remember how difficult it was to find a decent RT. We are set there for the next 8-10 years barring injury. What really tips me to not trading is the confidence I have in this team’s drafting ability. I would suppose it would depend on the evaluation they have given to the LT prospects in the draft.
|
No trading smith.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk |
Definitely not trading Braden.
|
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:56 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
ColtFreaks.com is in no way affiliated with the Indianapolis Colts, the NFL, or any of their subsidiaries.